Download Ebook The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber
This is not about exactly how considerably this book The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber costs; it is not likewise for what kind of e-book you truly like to review. It is concerning what you could take and also obtain from reading this The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber You can favor to select various other e-book; yet, no matter if you try to make this book The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber as your reading option. You will not regret it. This soft documents publication The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber could be your buddy regardless.
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber
Download Ebook The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber
Is The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber publication your favourite reading? Is fictions? How's regarding past history? Or is the best vendor unique your selection to satisfy your spare time? And even the politic or spiritual publications are you searching for now? Right here we go we provide The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber book collections that you need. Great deals of numbers of books from lots of industries are given. From fictions to science and also spiritual can be searched and learnt here. You could not fret not to find your referred publication to review. This The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber is among them.
As one of the home window to open the brand-new world, this The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber offers its fantastic writing from the writer. Released in among the prominent authors, this book The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber becomes one of one of the most ideal books lately. Really, the book will not matter if that The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber is a best seller or otherwise. Every book will consistently give ideal sources to obtain the reader all finest.
Nevertheless, some people will seek for the best vendor book to check out as the initial recommendation. This is why; this The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber is presented to fulfil your requirement. Some people like reading this publication The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber due to this preferred publication, however some love this because of preferred author. Or, many also like reading this publication The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber due to the fact that they really have to read this book. It can be the one that actually enjoy reading.
In getting this The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber, you could not constantly go by strolling or using your electric motors to the book establishments. Get the queuing, under the rainfall or very hot light, and still hunt for the unidentified book to be because book store. By visiting this web page, you could only hunt for the The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber and you can locate it. So currently, this time around is for you to go for the download web link and purchase The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber as your own soft documents publication. You could read this book The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber in soft file just and wait as your own. So, you do not should hurriedly put the book The Mons Myth: A Reassessment Of The Battle, By Terence Zuber right into your bag everywhere.
Conventional histories of the battles of Mons and Le Cateau describe how, although the British were massively outnumbered, precise and rapid British rifle fire mowed down rows of German troops. The staggering German casualties made these battles British victories, and set the stage for the Battle of the Marne. Neither battle has ever been described in English from the German point of view. Using German tactics manuals and regimental histories, The Mons Myth describes the battles at Mons and Le Cateau. It also subjects British tactics to a critique that goes beyond admiration for rapid rifle fire and presents new and startling perspectives of both Mons and Le Cateau, showing how the Germans employed a high degree of tactical sophistication in conducting a combined-arms battle. The odds at both battles were, in fact, even, and German casualties never reached the levels described in the standard histories. The Mons Myth is the first history of these battles to take this approach in ninety years.
- Sales Rank: #1931306 in Books
- Published on: 2010-04-01
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.50" h x 1.10" w x 6.00" l, 1.38 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 304 pages
About the Author
Terence Zuber was an officer in the US Army for twenty years—from 1970 to 1990. Parachute-qualified, he served with the infantry and as a staff officer, and spent eight years conducting counter-intelligence operations against the Stasi, for which he was awarded the Legion of Merit. A history graduate of the University of Minnesota, after leaving the army he went on to gain a doctorate from the the University of Würzburg, and is the author of German War Planning 1891-1914, Inventing the Schlieffen Plan, and The Battle of the Frontiers, as well as numerous articles in History Today, Intelligence & National Security, and War in History. He lives in West Virginia.
Most helpful customer reviews
28 of 30 people found the following review helpful.
A Welcome Reappraisal
By J. Scarborough
"The Mons Myth" by Terence Zuber is a welcome addition to the historical literature of the Great War. In reading the book, I wondered, "Why didn't anybody write this book before?" All the sources were there. But only Zuber set out to collect and review them. "Why aren't other historians doing this?"
For this reason, I think Zuber is the most significant military historian writing about World War One today. His work seems to have the pattern of digging out obscure (at least in English) sources and presenting a fresh look at what they provide (consider his challenge to the dogma of the Schlieffen Plan as a warplan). However, his polemic, in your face, writing style will prevent him from winning academic awards and acclaim for his work. Those invested in history as written will not appreciate Zuber's work.
"The Mons Myth" begins with a survey of sources, both British & German. Zuber looks at German regimental histories in a systematic way to present an account of the Mons and LeCateau very different than presented in British histories. J.E. Edmonds, author of the British official history, called Mons & LeCateau British military victories (Shades of "The Princess Bride," I had always wondered if Edmonds knew what those words meant).
Following the opening chapter is a presentation on tactical doctrine and training comparing the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) with the German Army. This chapter will be familiar to readers of Zuber's prior book, "Ardennes 1914 - The Battle of the Frontiers."
Then we get to the meat of the work, a thorough description of the German First Army's march through Belgium, and a day-by-day detailed look at the clash of the First Army with the BEF. Zuber presents a telling case: The German Army of 1914 possessed a more mature tactical doctrine than the Belgians, French, or British; and trained it; the German Army of 1914 was better trained than the Belgians, French, or British. The static, linear defense of the BEF at Mons and LeCateau was inadequate in the face of well-applied German combined arms doctrine.
Despite my praise for the book, I rate it with only four-stars. I downgrade it due to the maps presented to support the text. I spent too much time searching for locations mentioned in the text, that were not to be found on the maps. However, I found the black and white photographs to be very illustrative of the open ground the German attacks had to cross - they were well worth including, as were the contemporary line sketches showing the German Army in action.
I recommend this book. If you have an interest in the Great War, read it.
24 of 26 people found the following review helpful.
Valuable examination of German tactics
By P. Hederer
I'll confine my comments primarily to the author's treatment of German infantry tactics and tacitcal peformance.
The author generalises a bit, taking examples from one, or a few units, and making sweeping statements about German effectiveness. For example, he sings the praises of the German "combined arms team" (a jarring modern term) but cooperation between artillery and infantry was, and remained, a problem in the German Army--especially during this phase of the war. Would have liked to see him use a broader selection of sources, as German tactical performance varied widely from unit to unit--especially in 1914.
He provides a pretty solid explanation of tactical ideas and procedures from the German perspective. The material used in the first 60 pages cover the topic of German tactics and will be valuable to non-German speakers--the material extracted from the regulations will be a valuable reference as well. Many German writers lamented that the lessons of these regulations were not learned (or accepted) by company-level officers, exactly those who would have to use them in the field in 1914.
I believe he has a higher opinion of German tactical prowess than the German had of themselves. There are numerous German inter-war articles detailing the shortcomings of German tactical performance. He's a bit harsh in his judgements, especially of von Kuhl.
His rather odd commentary will most likely irritate many readers, but this overlooked, and with some watering down his black and white declarations, a valuable book for describing German tactical doctrine and techniques (especially in English)--read the conclusions with caution.
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful.
A bit dry, but a good counterpoint to Anglocentric Histories
By Bruce Rogers
Zuber's book is a bit dry - and I love detailed histories - but his research into the actual casualties and the impact of forces engaged shows that the post-war British assertions do not add up. One review criticizes Zuber for not detailing the Rape of Belgium. Fair enough. Zuber's work does, however, cast real doubt on the canard of "the Germans thought that the BEF was all machine guns" myth that was first promulgated in an unsourced assertion in the British official history. In some times numbing detail, Zuber demonstrates that at Mons the forces engaged were roughly equal - as were the casualties. At Le Cateau the British out numbered the Germans but were soundly beaten. In tandem with his book on the Ardennes battles, Zuber shows that the French inflicted as many casualties on the Germans as did the vaunted BEF. The British tactical triumph was as much a patriotic myth as were the archers of Agincourt/Angel of Mons stories. Fortuntely, however, German tactical expertise and flexibility were undone by unforced errors in German generalship. As with 1918, tactical superiority could not make up for strategic incompetence. Something the Germans never learned. So, well worth the read, if a bit dry.
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber PDF
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber EPub
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber Doc
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber iBooks
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber rtf
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber Mobipocket
The Mons Myth: A Reassessment of the Battle, by Terence Zuber Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment